"Just Use My SIM": 5 Myths About Signing Up With a Friend's or Relative's Number
Say a woman sets up an account in a delivery app using her brother's number. She doesn't want to give out her own, and he doesn't mind. Six months later she gets a new phone, the app asks for a login code, and the SMS goes to her brother, who is on a plane at that very moment. Technically, you can register an account on a relative's number. The trouble starts the day the account needs a code again.
Myth 1. It's free
You don't pay any money, but you do depend on someone else's schedule. A login code is usually valid for only a few minutes. If your relative is driving, asleep, or not looking at their phone, your login gets pushed back to the evening, and texts like "hey, did the code come through?" turn into a habit. After a few failed attempts, many services temporarily stop sending codes, so the wait gets even longer.
Myth 2. Recovery codes will still end up with me
For most services, your phone number is the main proof that the account belongs to you. Login codes, password resets, and alerts about sign-ins from a new device all go to your relative's phone. They're unlikely to use this against you, but phones get lost and go in for repairs. On top of that, they can see which services you sign up for, and they forward codes as screenshots in a messaging app, where the codes stay. In this arrangement, neither of you has any privacy.
Myth 3. The number will stay theirs forever
People move, switch carriers, and toss a second SIM they haven't used in ages. After that, the account is tied to a number that neither you nor they own. You both lose access: they can no longer receive the code for you, and you can't get it yourself. An account like that is hard to recover, because the service often has no other way to confirm who owns it. And if the carrier eventually reassigns the number to a new subscriber, your codes will start going to a stranger.
Myth 4. It's no trouble for your relative
Many services allow only one account per phone number. Your brother decides to create his own profile in the same app and finds out the number is already taken. Now he faces an awkward choice: unlink your account or go without the service. Then there are the newsletters and notifications from apps he doesn't even use. And if you physically took the SIM card, he's left without a number until you give it back.
Myth 5. Renting a number solves all the same problems
For short tasks, renting a number on a marketplace is more convenient than borrowing someone's SIM, since you don't have to involve family. A one-time activation holds the number for one hour, and the exact time is set in the catalog for each service. If you'll need a code more than once, go with a 1-, 3-, or 7-day rental: repeat codes to that number are free until the rental ends. When you order, you'll only see the durations sold for the selected service. You can check each supplier's price and availability before paying, even without signing in, and then buy from your account.
If the time on a one-time activation runs out and the code never arrives, the money goes back to your internal balance automatically. You have to cancel a rental with no code yourself within the first hour after purchase, before any SMS or call arrives: after that it is paid even if the code never arrives. You can also cancel an order before the code arrives, but only after at least a minute has passed since purchase. Refunds go only to your balance, not to a card or wallet. Once the SMS is received, the service counts as delivered, and the code doesn't guarantee a successful sign-up on a third-party service. That decision is up to the service itself.
For long-lived accounts, a rental has the same weakness as a relative's number: the number isn't yours. The SIM sits in the supplier's equipment, and your SMS messages pass through it. After the rental ends, you can buy the same number again if the SIM is still online. If it has gone offline, you can send the supplier a request to bring it back into service, but whether they do is out of our hands. Link your main email, the messenger you've used for years, and any accounts with payment details to your own number, and where the service allows it, turn on sign-in with an authenticator app.
If the task is short, don't ask your family for their SIM. Open the catalog, pick a service and a country, and get a one-time activation or a 1-, 3-, or 7-day rental. You can pick a supplier yourself based on price and stock, or skip that step, and the number will come from the cheapest one.